When less equals More Jan 1, 2008 12:00 PM
, BY MICHELLE EICHNER AND LEN SHNEYDER
JobZone
Search and post jobs for the Multichannel Merchant. Including jobs for brand & agency marketers, e-commerce, catalog marketers, ops & fulfillment, direct marketing and more.
Investigating the root causes behind your risk profile.
Why are they unsubscribing? People will unsubscribe no matter how good
the offer or clever the creative. Names in the zero to three month
range typically have a lower unsubscribe rate than names in the four to
six or seven to nine month ranges. Based on the blue line in the chart,
you can see that this middle age group is actively unsubscribing. This
may be because they have acquired the product or service they need and
may no longer be as engaged with your messages as they were in their
information gathering stages.
As
customers in the continuum age and transform from recent to older
clients, it can be inferred that you've built a positive rapport,
loyalty and a high lifetime value with those customers. But the
difference in terms of unsubscribes/complaints/bad addresses between
segments should prompt responsible marketers to ask pointed questions
to shed light on why and how these differences occur:
Is it the way that names have been acquired?
Are communications being tailored to fit the age of the segment?
Am
I reviewing unsubscribes/complaints/bad addresses by age of name in my
database to isolate how I'm impacting segments through my messaging
strategy?
Why are they complaining? Permission levels.
The first and most obvious reason customers may report your e-mails as
spam to their ISPs is that they didn't actually give you explicit
permission to e-mail — or forgot they did. At this point, it may be
time to revisit your definition vs. your customers' definition of
explicit permission.
Questionable identity.
A second important reason is that your customer may not recognize that
the e-mail is from you. Vanity from-addresses, non-descriptive subject
lines, and image-blocking all work to your disadvantage.
Today
it's just as important to sell the content of the e-mail as it is to
ensure your company brand is clearly recognizable. Do so by ensuring
your company is identifiable in either the from line or subject line of
the e-mail, and that your content does not require images-on to convey
your brand and key calls to action.
Report spam buttons.
Unfortunately, regardless of how well crafted your message or universal
your brand, someone will complain. To understand why complaints may
occur even when you follow a clear opt-in acquisition strategy, it's
necessary to understand the report-as-spam button.
Abuses
of non-functioning e-mail unsubscribe mechanisms prompted consumer
distrust of mailers' unsubscribe options. ISPs, forced to come up with
a tool that would allow recipients to help them identify illegitimate
mailers and prevent further messaging abuses, introduced the
report-as-spam button. These are now a highly visible and easy-to-use
feature in most major e-mail readers. Consumers use it not only to
report real or suspected spam, but also as an alternative to the
unsubscribe option provided by the mailer.
While
it is impossible to avoid spam complaints alltogether, feedback loops
offered by many ISPs give mailers the ability to quickly remove users
from their active list and prevent subsequent complaints. But if an ISP
or domain offers a feedback loop — and you haven't signed up for it —
then complaints will continue to mount and so, too, will the
probability that the ISP will revoke your right to mail any customer at
their domain
How old is too old?
Some ISPs will say any address that hasn't responded in six months
should never be mailed again. The only way to answer this question is
to grab hold of your monitor and peer deep into the soul of your
database.
As
complaints and unsubscribes taper off, the specter of bad addresses
replaces them. In the oldest segments we see an increase in bad
addresses as people change e-mail addresses/jobs/ISPs and so on.
Old
segments pose the greatest threat of being blocked because they're most
likely to have the highest numbers of complaints and bad addresses;
combined volumes of both are a clear and present danger to an ISP
striving to protect its users (your customers) from phishers and
spammers. Such as ISP is likely to block a mailer who is not proactive
in removing complaints and bad addresses.
Once
you have established which segments are generating more complaints and
bounces than opens and clicks, you should ascertain where these e-mail
addresses originated. Can you account for the source or method of
acquisition? If not, you may consider putting them back where you found
them.
How
old is too old, you might ask again? Too old is anything that you can't
account for in terms of its provenance — and those generating higher
numbers of bounces and complaints when compared to your most active and
recent segments.
How can I send less e-mail and still meet my business goals?
If the idea behind more equals less is rooted in the nature and mode of
your communication with your clients, there are definite paths to
achieving greater ROI. Here are three: